Statistics for occurrence #1 of “A. P. Hill” in chapter 4.36, section c.4.36.54, page 203 of Southern Historical Society Papers, Volume 10.:
... right, ran against Porter and some Federal artillery that had taken position at Malvern under the fire of the gunboats in James river, and Holmes was quickly and completely checked.
Longstreet and A. P. Hill , however, attacked
...