Statistics for occurrence #1 of “Hildreth” in chapter 6, page 117 of Thomas Wentworth Higginson, Henry Walcott Boynton, Reader's History of American Literature:
...in that day thought eloquent, but now felt to be overstrained and inflated; William H. Prescott, with attractive but colorless style and rather superficial interpretation; Ticknor, dull and accurate; Hildreth , extremely dry; Palfrey, more graceful, but one-sided;
...