Statistics for occurrence #1 of “Capt. I. B. Carthel” in chapter 7, page 101 of James D. Porter, Confederate Military History, a library of Confederate States Military History: Volume 7.1, Tennessee:
...
Colonel Vaughan, commanding the brigade after Smith's fall, reported the capture of 300 prisoners and the colors of the Seventy-seventh Pennsylvania regiment, sent back to the division commander by Capt. I. B. Carthel , Forty-seventh Tennessee.
Under a misapprehension General Cleburne reported the capture of the colors by his own command.
During the battle of the day and night Cheatham lost
...