s Cambridge authors.
It is well known that Emerson distrusted the sombre tone of Hawthorne's writings and advised young people not to read them; and that Judge Hoar, Emerson's inseparable friend, could conceive of no reason why any one should wish to see Thoreau's Journals published.
Among the Knickerbocker circles in New York it seems to have been still worse, Cooper the novelist, says Parke Godwin, always brought a breeze of quarrel with him.
Cooper wrote thus to Rufus W. Griswold (August 7, 1842): A published eulogy of myself from Irving's pen could not change my opinion of his career .... Cuvier has the same faults as Irving, and so had Scott.
They were all meannesses, and I confess I can sooner pardon crimes, if they are manly ones.
I have never had any quarrel with Mr. Irving, and give him full credit as a writer.
Still I believe him to be below the ordinary level, in moral qualities, instead of being above them, as he is cried up to be.
He adds: Bryant is worth forty Irv