[286]
So much has been said and written about Harper's Ferry and the surrender of the garrison, that it seems difficult to pass it without notice.
In more than one report General McClellan mentioned it as a “shameful” surrender.
He had disapproved the position as false, and asked if it could not be given up. Colonel Miles, the commander, who gave his life in its defence, was acting under the following order from the department commander,viz.:
The simple truth is, it was defended to the last extremity.
The nearer the approach of the succoring army, the more imperative would have been the demand for action on the part of the Confederate columns, and had battle been forced it could not possibly have resulted in any save one way,--Confederate victory, and an overwhelming one at that.
The position was denounced as a “man-trap,” and so it proved to Colonel Miles and his eleven thousand troops, but it was in fact a far more formidable trap for the Confederates, who to seize it sacrificed the fruits of heavy war,--victory in the main battle of the campaign,--and were forced to draw their crippled ranks to homeward defence.
General Jackson wanted it till he got possession; then gave it up. General McClellan wanted to give it up before it was taken.
After it had been taken
1 Rebellion Record, vol. XIX. part i. p. 520.
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.
An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.