previous next

With c. 99 begins the third part of Book II, i. e. the history of Egypt. This divides (at c. 147) into two parts: (a) the story of Egypt as told by the Egyptians themselves, and (b) that which is based in part on the evidence of other nations, i. e. the story after the opening of Egypt to the Greeks by Psammetichus. H. recognizes the difference in the evidence for these two parts, though he does not appreciate how great it was (cf. 147 n. and App. X. 10; Introd. § 27).

Μῖνα. The Egyptian form MNA left the vowel to be supplied; hence the various forms Μήνης (Manetho), Μῆνας (Diodorus), Μιναῖος (Josephus). Menes was long considered an invention, and used to be quoted as an instance of H.'s credulity; but the tomb of the king (Aha) identified with him was discovered in 1897 at Nagada near Abydos (Petrie, i. 17), and more fully explored in 1904 (King and Hall, pp. 57, 64). He seems to have united the crowns of Upper and Lower Egypt, and so to begin a new epoch (circ. 3400 B. C.).

τοῦτο μέν: repeated in § 4 τοῦτο μὲν ἐν αὐτῷ, and answers to τοῦτο δέ at end of chapter.

ἀπογεφυρῶσαι, &c., lit. ‘dammed off’, i. e. by diverting the river's course (§ 2) and ‘making it a new channel’ (ὀχετεῦσαι), he secured the site for building Memphis.

τὸν πρὸς μεσαμβρίης, κτλ.: translate ‘he made with dykes the bend (which lies) to the south’. The Nile makes a great bend to the east, fourteen miles to the south of Memphis; but ‘it is impossible to say if there is any truth in H.'s tradition’ (Maspero, p. 53). Breasted (p. 37; cf. also E. E. F., Report for 1905, p. 39) accepts it, and Murray (pp. 188-9) shows that its distance from Memphis here given is very accurate.


ἔτι καὶ νῦν. H.'s words imply that the Persians were in undisputed possession of Memphis (cf. App. IX. 1). There is no trace of lakes near Memphis; H. may be misled by the Nile flood filling the canal, the Bahr Yûssûf; its dry bed can still be seen to the north and west of Memphis. But Diodorus (i. 96) speaks of the Acherusian lake near Memphis, the circuit of which city he makes seventeen miles, and Murray (u. s.) accepts this as a fact. Cf. 97. 2 for the time of H's visit.

τὸ ἱρόν. This temple—that of Ptah—is most important as the probable source of H.'s information as to Egyptian history (cf. App. X. 10).

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.

An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.

hide Display Preferences
Greek Display:
Arabic Display:
View by Default:
Browse Bar: