Third joint debate, at Jonesboro, September 15, 1858.
Ladies and Gentlemen
: I appear before you to-day in pursuance of a previous notice, and have made arrangements with Mr. Lincoln
to divide time, and discuss with him the leading political topics that now agitate the country.
Prior to 1854 this country was divided into two great political parties known as Whig and Democratic.
These parties differed from each other on certain questions which were then deemed to be important to the best interests of the Republic
Whig and Democrats differed about a bank, the tariff, distribution, the specie circular and the sub-treasury.
On those issues we went before the country and discussed the principles, objects and measures of the two great parties.
Each of the parties could proclaim its principles in Louisiana
as well as in Massachusetts
, in Kentucky
as well as in Illinois
Since that period, a great revolution has taken place in the formation of parties, by which they now seem to be divided by a geographical line, a large party in the North
being arrayed under the Abolition or Republican banner, in hostility to the Southern States
, Southern people, and Southern institutions.
It becomes important for us to inquire how this transformation of parties has occurred, made from those of national principles to geographical factions.
You remember that in 1850--this country was agitated from its center to its circumference about this slavery question — it became necessary for the leaders of the great Whig party and the leaders of the great Democratic party to postpone, for the time being, their particular disputes, and unite first to save the Union
before they should quarrel as to the mode in which it was to be governed.
During the Congress
of 1849--1850, Henry Clay
was the leader of the Union
men, supported by Cass
, and the leaders of the Democracy and the leaders of the Whigs
, in opposition to Northern Abolitionists or Southern Disunionists.
That great contest of 1850 resulted in the establishment of the Compromise Measures
of that year, which measures rested on the great principle that the people of each State and each Territory of this Union ought to be permitted to regulate their own domestic institutions in their own way, subject to no other limitation than that which the Federal Constitution
I now wish to ask you whether that principle was right or wrong which guarantied to every State and every community the right to form and regulate their domestic institutions to suit themselves.
These measures were adopted, as I have previously said, by the joint action of the Union Whigs
and Union Democrats in opposition to Northern Abolitionists and Southern Disunionists.
In 1858, when the Whig party assembled at Baltimore
, in National Convention for the last time, they adopted the principle of the Compromise Measures
of 1850 as their rule of party action in the future.
One month thereafter the Democrats assembled at the same place to nominate a candidate for the Presidency, and declared the same great principle as the rule of action by which the Democracy would be governed.
The Presidential election of 1852 was fought on that basis.
true that the Whigs
claimed special merit for the adoption of those measures, because they asserted that their great Clay
originated them, their god-like Webster
defended them and their Fillmore
signed the bill making them the law of the land; but on the other hand, the Democrats claimed special credit for the Democracy, upon the