corps, and Smith
's corps coming from Missouri
), in which he included about 8000 or 10,000 new troops at Nashville
, and the same number of civil employees of the quartermaster's department.
The Fourth and Twenty-third corps he estimated at 27,000 men, and Smith
's at 10,000, and the cavalry in the field at 7700.
All this was sufficiently accurate if no account were taken of men unfit for duty or not equipped.
But the official returns show that the number of officers and men present for duty equipped amounted to 29,322 in the department, and in the two corps in the field to 24,265, and in the cavalry in the field, to 4800.
There were therefore the following discrepancies in Sherman
's estimate, due in part to the discharge of men whose terms had expired, as well as to the usual number of men not equipped for duty in the ranks: in the troops in the department, a discrepancy of 8000; in the army corps in the field, 2735; in the cavalry in the field, 29001
—a total discrepancy of 13,635.
That is to say, Sherman
's own estimate was in excess of Thomas
's actual strength by a force greater than either of the two army corps he sent back to help Thomas
If he had sent back another large corps,—say the Fourteenth, 13,000 strong, having besides the moral strength due to the fact that it was Thomas
's old corps,—the discrepancy in his own estimate would doubtless have been sufficiently overcome, and the line of Duck River
at least, if not that of the Tennessee
, as Sherman
had assured Grant
, would have been securely held until A. J. Smith
arrived and Thomas
could assume the offensive.
's force was ready to invade Tennessee