country were ‘as familiar as a nursery tale,’ whereas they were wholly unknown to General Johnston
It was, therefore, both natural and just that General Beauregard
should have the actual command of the army, as he certainly had the responsibility for the issue of the contest.
was in command, not of the ‘left’ only, but of our whole line, including the left, the centre, and the right.
He issued orders to all our united forces then gathered on the field, the ‘new field,’ which, General Johnson
says, had been substituted for the first.
On that ‘field’ did he command, fight, and win the battle, while General Johnston
, at his request, had gone to the rear to assist him by sending forward reinforcements.
Not once during the whole battle did General Johnston
give him a single order.
All orders on the evening previous, as well as on that day, were, as we have seen, suggested and issued by General Beauregard
, and acquiesced in by General Johnston
From the moment the latter withdrew from the field, at 11.30 A. M., or about that time, until 4.30 P. M., when General Beauregard
joined him at the Lewis House
, he communicated only once with General Beauregard
, and then, only to send him an unimportant message, through Colonel Lay
, one of his aids.
So might have done, and so did, Colonel Jordan
, General Beauregard
's Chief of Staff
, and other subordinate officers, whose duty it was to inform the commanding general
of all that occurred in their front, with a view to receiving further instructions from him.
Suppose General Beauregard
, yielding to General Johnston
's reluctance to take the position he had indicated for him at the Lewis House
, had gone thither himself, would that have put General Beauregard
in command of the ‘whole field’?
Yet that is the very position General Johnston
would have wished General Beauregard
to take, had not the latter ‘claimed’ the command, which, for the reasons so often alluded to, had been given him by General Johnston
If the position taken by General Johnston
, at the request of General Beauregard
, was the proper one to be taken by the commander of the army, he should have gone thither of his own free will, as soon as ‘order was restored and the battle re-established.’
But he insisted upon remaining with the troops immediately engaged, and upon doing what General Beauregard
actually did. Was it because he was the commander of the army?
If the Lewis House
was not the position