History of the civil war in America
By the Comte de Paris
Vol. III. Philadelphia
We are indebted to the publishers for a copy of this book, which is beautifully gotten up in the best style of the bookmaker's art.
We have also received (we presume through the courtesy of the distinguished author) a beautiful copy of the French
edition of the work so far as completed.
The reviews of the former volumes which we have published have given our readers an idea of the general character of the work.
But while reserving for the future a detailed review of this third volume, we must say that the Count
has had much richer material with which to write this volume, that he seems to have made a better use of his material, and that it seems to be fairer to the Confederates
than its predecessors.
And yet when we come to discuss it in detail (as we hope to do by the pens of some of our most competent military critics), we expect to show that the Count
still writes more in the spirit of the partizan than with the calm judgment of the impartial Foreign Historian.
We acknowledge his courteous mention of Southern Historical Society Papers
and their editor, and only regret that he has not studied more carefully our pages, and made better use of the facts and figures we have given him, and to which we shall hereafter call special attention.
Meantime we advise all interested in such matters to procure the book, that they may see for themselves what this foreign prince has to say of Chancellorsville
Virginia Historical collections.
Vol. III. New series.
Vol. I. 1751-1755.
Edited by R. A. Brock
, Correspondent Secretary
, and published by the Virginia Historical Society.
This book (for a copy of which we are indebted to the editor) is a credit to all concerned.
The printer (W. Ellis Jones
) and the binders (J. W. Randolph
) have done their work admirably, while Mr. Brock
displays his usual taste and historic research in his introduction and in his valuable notes on the text.
It is needless to add that a collection of letters and papers concerning events which transpired during the important and stirring period of colonial history from 1751 to 1755 cannot fail to be of deep interest and permanent historic value, and as these papers are published for the first time from the original Mss. they are only now brought within reach of the historian, and will prove a rich mine in which he can work.
The Virginia Historical Society is indebted to the enlightened liberality of W. W. Corcoran
, Esqr., for their possession of these papers and their ability to use them, and they have very properly accompanied the volume with a fine likeness of the great philanthropist, and his autograph letter making the valuable gift.
The few extra copies for sale will, of course, be bought up at once, as no historic collection could be called complete without the ‘Dinwiddie Papers
recollections of A naval officer.
1841-1865. By Captain William Hamar Parker
New York: Charles Scribner
We have received, ‘with the compliments of the author,’ through West
& Co., Richmond
, this beautifully gotten up book, and have time and space now only to say that a slight dipping into its pages shows conclusively that our gallant Confederate tar knows how to wield a pen as well as how to sail or fight a ship, and has produced a book of rare interest and decided historic value.
We mean to give it a careful reading, and shall hereafter copy for our readers some of its good things, such as the account of ‘The Merimac
and the Monitor
's-eye view of our civil war. By Colonel T. A. Dodge
, U. S. A. Boston
: lames R. Osgood
After reading Colonel Dodge
's admirable book on ‘Chancellorsville
,’ we were prepared to find in this new publication a well written, calm, and unusually fair book.
We have not been disappointed, and while we are not, of course, prepared to accept all of Colonel Dodge
's statements, or to endorse all of his criticisms, we do not hesitate to commend the book most warmly as the work of an able, pains-taking soldier, who has honestly endeavored to ascertain, and frankly to tell the truth about our late war.
We propose hereafter to make copious extracts from Colonel Dodge
and to publish a fuller review of his interesting and valuable contribution to a history of the war.
& Co, have done their part of the work admirably, and have produced a fine specimen of the book-makers' art.
across the continent with the Fifth cavalry.
By Captain George F. Price
New York: D. Van Nostrand
A narrative of this famous old regiment (formerly the Second Cavalry
) could not fail to be of interest, and we commend the beautifully gotten up volume as worthy of a place on the shelves of our ‘War Libraries.’
But we must express now our regret that the author could not drop the partisan
and write more in the spirit of the true soldier
, and our purpose to show up hereafter some of his more glaring perversions of the truth of history.
Brook Farm to Cedar Mountain
, in the war of the rebellion; 1861-1862.
By General George H. Gordon
: James R. Osgood
We reserve for future review this admirably written and very interesting book which is a part of the series of which the ‘Army of Virginia
’ and ‘A War Diary
’ form a continuous history of the war.
writes with a free pen, and some of his criticisms on ‘the blundering stupidity of political managers in Washington
, acting upon the colossal incapacity of their favorites in the field,’ are very rich.
We commend the book as well worth reading and preserving.
the century keeps up its high standard of excellence, and the November number contains a very readable paper on the retreat from Richmond
, and capture of President Davis
, by his private secretary, Burton N. Harrison