teeth were found in hir mouth and that she was coming five years old.’
One witness testified ‘shee was going six years old’ and had never been branded.
It is evident that the mare and colt claimed Josiah Converse
as their owner and his farm as their home.
As the mare would not remain at the Collins farm
, and could not be of much use to him, it is probable the jury thought best to legally return the ‘unrewly’ pets to Converse
, and it decided in the second trial that the mare and colt belonged to Converse
, thus reversing the decision in the first trial.
Thus the controversy ended, as many law suits do at present, with no advantage to either side, except that Deacon Josiah Converse
successfully defended his good name against the reputation it might have obtained in the highest circle of Medford
's colonial society of his being a horse thief.
The next neighborhood dispute to which attention is called is that of the Rev. Zachariah Symmes
, first minister of the Charlestown church, with Mr. Thomas Broughton
and Mr. Edward Collins
, both of Medford
These three gentlemen were men of distinction in their day. The ministers of the early colonial churches were often paid for their services with other ‘considerations’ than pounds, shillings and pence.
Land was cheap, and much of it was given to the ministers.
Both John Harvard
and Rev. Zachariah Symmes
were presented with farms in ancient ‘Waterfield,’ the locality now known as Winchester
but originally belonging to Charlestown
This fact may account for the high moral tone for which the town of Winchester
has always been celebrated!
The Harvard farm
was situated near the present Catholic cemetery in Winchester
, and the Symmes farm
, of several hundred acres, was situated at head of Mystic lake
, and extended nearly to present Winchester
The first Symmes house was erected in the center of the Winchester
playground, and was occupied and afterwards owned by William Symmes
, the only son of Zachariah.
There are several homesteads in Winchester
now owned by descendants of Zachariah Symmes
which have never