Statistics for occurrence #1 of “Dr. Bates” in chapter 5 of Southern Historical Society Papers, Volume 4.:
...d Gettysburg, as Dr. Bates imagines, he brought almost his entire force to the latter point.
Hoping will carefully examine the original sources of information in regard to the matters treated by Dr. Bates , whose book may be conscientiously, but is certainly not carefully compiled, I am, most truly yours,
W. Allan.
...