rds, No State shall withdraw from the Union without the consent of all the States convened in pursuance of an act passed by two-thirds of each House of Congress.
This was rejected by a vote of 11 States against 10.
The votes were by States.
When, on the same day, the majority report was taken up for final action, Baldwin's proposition, offered as a substitute, was rejected by a vote of 13 States against 8.
Seddon then offered his substitute, and it was rejected—16 States against 4. James B. Clay, a son of Henry Clay, then offered Crittenden's compromise.
It was rejected by 14 States against 5.
Guthrie's report was then taken up, and after some modifications was adopted.
Following this, T. E. Franklin moved, as the sense of the convention, that the highest political duty of every citizen of the United States is allegiance to the national government, and that no State has a constitutional right to secede therefrom.
It was rejected by 10 States against 7. Mr. Guthrie offered