Here Ammonius began to speak, saying: In my
opinion, Theophrastus was in the right, and spoke like a
philosopher and a divine; for whoever shall deny what he
alleges must also reject many things which may happen,
though we understand not the reasons why they do so.
And granting what he offers to be true, it carries with it
many things called impossible and unreal. But as to what I
have heard the Epicureans allege against the Daemons which
Empedocles brings in,—as, that it is impossible they can
be happy and long-lived if they be bad and viciously
affected, because vice in its own nature is blind and naturally precipitates itself into such mischiefs as destroy life,
—that, I must tell you, is vain and idle. For if this
[p. 26]
reasoning be good, it will then follow that Epicurus was a
worse man than Gorgias the sophister, and Metrodorus
than Alexis the comic actor; for Alexis lived twice as long
as Metrodorus, and Gorgias a third longer than Epicurus.
For it is in another regard we say virtue is strong and vice
weak. not in reference to the continuance or dissolution of
the body; for we know there are many animals which are
dull, slow, and heavy, and many disorderly and lustful,
which live longer than those that are more sagacious and
quicker of sense. And therefore they are much in the
wrong in saying the divine nature is immortal because it
avoideth the things which are ill and mischievous; for they
should have supposed the divine nature free from all possibility of falling into corruption and alteration. But perhaps it will be thought not fair to dispute against those
that are absent; I would have therefore Cleombrotus to
resume his discourse touching the vanishing and transmigration of Daemons from one place to another.
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.
An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.