Chapter 6: “contraband of War,” Big Bethel and Hatteras.
- Captured negroes declared to be “contraband of War”
-- story of the origin of the phrase
-- possibly not good law, but a handy expedient
-- sensation created
-- some remarks concerning Mr. John Hay as a historian
-- difficulty in obtaining horses
-- Decides to dislodge Confederate forces at Bethel
-- order for detail of the movement
-- gross mismanagement of plans
-- Union troops fire upon each other
-- in front of the breastworks
-- orders disobeyed and attack given up
-- enemy's condition investigated
-- battle of Bull Run
-- General Wool sent to Fortress Monroe
-- attack on the forts at Hatteras
-- their surrender
-- midnight ride to Washington
-- telling welcome news to the President
-- a Waltz en Dishabille
-- goes home to Lowell
-- the battle of Bull Run critically considered
On the day after my arrival at the fort, May 23, three negroes were reported coming in a boat from Sewall's Point
, where the enemy was building a battery.
Thinking that some information as to that work might be got from them, I had them before me. I learned that they were employed on the battery on the Point
, which as yet was a trifling affair.
There were only two guns there, though the work was laid out to be much.
larger and to be heavily mounted with guns captured from the navy-yard.
The negroes said they belonged to Colonel Mallory
, who commanded the Virginia
troops around Hampton
, and that he was now making preparation to take all his negroes to Florida
soon, and that not wanting to go away from home they had escaped to the fort.
I directed that they should be fed and set at work.
On the next day I was notified by an officer in charge of the picket line next Hampton
that an officer bearing a flag of truce desired to be admitted to the fort to see me. As I did not wish to allow officers of the enemy to come inside the fort just then and see us piling up sand bags to protect the weak points there, I directed the bearer of the flag to be informed that I would be at the picket line in the course of an hour.
Accompanied by two gentlemen of my staff, Major Fay
and Captain Haggerty
, neither now living, I rode out to the picket line and met the flag of truce there.
It was under charge of Major Carey
, who introduced himself, at the same time pleasantly calling to mind that we last met at the Charleston convention. Major Carey
opened the conversation by saying: “I have sought to see you for the purpose of ascertaining upon what principles you intend to conduct the war in this neighborhood.”
I expressed my
willingness to answer, and the major said: “I ask first whether a passage through the blockading fleet will be allowed to families and citizens of Virginia
who desire to go North to a place of safety.”
“The presence of the families of the belligerents,” I replied, “is always the best hostage for their good behavior.
One of the objects of the blockade is to prevent the admission of supplies and provisions into Virginia
while she is hostile to the government.
Reducing the number of consumers would necessarily tend to defeat the object in view.
Passing a vessel through the blockade would involve so much trouble and delay, by way of examination to prevent frauds and abuse of the privilege, that I feel myself under the necessity of refusing.”
“Will the passage of families desiring to go North be permitted?”
asked Major Carey
“With the exception of an interruption at Baltimore
, which has now been disposed of, travel of peaceable citizens through to the North
has not been hindered; and as to the internal line through Virginia
, your friends have, for the present, entire control of it. The authorities at Washington
will settle that question, and I must leave it to be disposed of by them.”
“I am informed,” said Major Carey
, “that three negroes belonging to Colonel Mallory
have escaped within your lines.
I am Colonel Mallory
's agent and have charge of his property.
What do you mean to do with those negroes?”
“I intend to hold them,” said I.
“Do you mean, then, to set aside your constitutional obligation to return them?”
“I mean to take Virginia
at her word, as declared in the ordinance of secession passed yesterday.
I am under no constitutional obligations to a foreign country, which Virginia
now claims to be.”
“But you say we cannot secede,” he answered, “and so you cannot consistently detain the negroes.”
“But you say you have seceded, so you cannot consistently claim them.
I shall hold these negroes as contraband of war, since they are engaged in the construction of your battery and are claimed as your property.
The question is simply whether they shall be used for or against the Government
of the United States
Yet, though I greatly need the labor which has providentially come to my hands,
if Colonel Mallory
will come into the fort and take the oath of allegiance to the United States
, he shall have his negroes, and I will endeavor to hire them from him.”
is absent,” was Major Carey
We courteously parted.
On the way back, the correctness of my law was discussed by Major Haggerty
, who was, for a young man, a very good lawyer.
He said that he doubted somewhat upon the law, and asked me if I knew of that proposition having been laid down in any treatise on international law.
“Not the precise proposition,” said I; “but the precise principle is familiar law. Property of whatever nature, used or capable of being used for warlike purposes, and especially when being so used, may be captured and held either on sea or on shore as property contraband of war. Whether there may be a property in human beings is a question upon which some of us might doubt, but the rebels cannot
take the negative.
At any rate, Haggerty
, it is a good enough reason to stop the rebels' mouths with, especially as I should have held these negroes anyway.”
At headquarters and in the fort nothing was discussed but the negro question, and especially this phase of it. The negroes came pouring in day by day, and the third day from that I reported the fact that more than $60,000 worth of them had come in; that I had found work for them to do, had classified them and made a list of them so that their identity might be fully assured, and had appointed a “commissioner of negro affairs” to take this business off my hands, for it was becoming onerous.
I wrote the lieutenant-general
that I awaited instructions but should pursue this course until I had received them.
On the 30th I received word front the Secretary of War
, to whom I had duplicated my letter to General Scott
His instructions gave me no directions to pursue any different course of action from that which I had reported to him, except that I was to keep an accurate account of the value of their work.
But the local effect of the position taken was of the slightest account compared with its effect upon the country at large.
The question of the disposal of the slaves was one that perplexed very many of the most ardent lovers of the country and loyal prosecutors of the war. It afforded a groundwork for discussion which yielded many excuses for those who did not desire the war to be carried on. In a word, the slave question was a stumbling-block.
Everybody saw that if the work of returning fugitive slaves to their masters in rebellion was imposed upon the Union
troops, it would never be done; the men would simply be disgusted and finally decline the duty.
Our troops could not act as a marshal's posse in catching runaway negroes to return them to their masters who were fighting us at the same time.
What ought to be done?
Nobody made answer to that question.
Fortuitously it was thrust upon me to decide what must be done then and there, and very fortunately a few moments' thought caused to flash through my mind the plausible answer at least to the question: What will you do?
I do not claim for the phrase “contraband of war,” used in this connection, the highest legal sanction, because it would not apply to property used or property for use in war, as would be a cargo of coal being carried to be burned on board an enemy's ship of war. To hold that contraband, as well might be done, by no means included all the coal in the country.
It was a poor phrase enough; Wendell Phillips
said “a bad one.”
My staff officer, Major Winthrop
, insisted it was an epigram which freed the slaves.
The truth is, as a lawyer I was never very proud of it, but as an executive officer I was very much comforted with it as a means of doing my duty.
The effect upon the public mind, however, was most wonderful.
Everybody seemed to feel a relief on this great slavery question.
Everybody thought a way had been found through it. Everybody praised its author by extolling its great use, but whether right or
wrong it paved the way for the President
's proclamation of freedom to the slaves within eighteen months afterwards.
There has been, so far as I know, in the several histories, but one very belittling account of the origin of this method of disposing of captured slaves used in war, and that one is the emanation of malice and ignorance in “Abraham Lincoln
, a history,” a book which was written by one man with two pens.
Mr. John Hay
Out of this incident seems to have grown one of the most sudden and important revolutions in popular thought which took place during the whole war. General Butler has had the credit of first pronouncing the opinion formulating the doctrine, that under the course of international law the negro slaves, whose enforced labor in battery building was at the time of superior military value to the rebels, are manifestly contraband of war, and as such confiscable by military right and usage.
There is no word or hint of this theory in his letter which reports the Mallory incident, nor any other official emanation of it by him until two months afterwards, when he stated casually that he had adopted such a theory.
Nevertheless it is very possible that the idea may have come from him, though not at first in any authentic or official form.
It first occurs incidentally in a newspaper letter from Fortress Monroe of the same date of the Mallory incident: “Again, the negro must now be reported as contraband, since every able-bodied negro not absolutely required on the plantation is impressed by the enemy into military service as a laborer on the various fortifications.”
Whether the suggestion was struck out in General Butler's interview with the flag bearer, or at general mess table in a confidential review of the day's work; or whether it originated with some imaginative member of his staff, or was contributed as a handy expedient by the busy brain of a newspaper reporter, will, perhaps, ever remain a historical riddle.
This double-named historian has stepped out of his way to attempt to rob me of the authorship of this theory of disposing of such captured slaves.
As he evidently did not understand the matter about which he was speaking, he has noted the fact that I did not ask, in my letter to General Scott
the morning after I met Colonel Mallory
's agent, as to this theory or use the word “contraband,” and has produced it as evidence that the phrase was not used by me in the interview as to captured slaves.
If he had read my letters to General Scott
he would have seen that I was asking
from him instructions how to deal with the whole question of negro slavery during the war.
As I have already said, I have never claimed and never believed that “contraband” alone would cover that.
That was the popular belief, not mine.
I was asking Scott
for instructions as to what I should do with the slave men, women, and children, sick and well, who came to me. I did not need any instructions from Scott
, neither of whom were lawyers, as to the legal question of the law of nations concerning captured slaves when used by their masters in actual warfare.
The question put and argued in those letters was: What was I to do with the slave population of the whole country who came to me voluntarily, men, women, and children.
I had $60,000 worth of them.
That question included the slaves of loyal men. In this matter I wanted the sanction of the government.
I had adopted a theory on this question for myself in Maryland
, and got rapped over the knuckles for it by Governor Andrew
I had learned what manner of man Scott
was, and I was desirous to take instructions from him for my action but not for my law.
If Mr. Hay
had stopped at the point where he was led to doubt my authorship of “contraband” because I had not mentioned it to Scott
, and was so misled, no more would need to be said.
The sin of ignorance “God winks at,” and I should follow that example.
But having been a newspaper man himself, and this being a great question of international law, which has never yet been settled, and which, as he argues, contributed largely to the freeing of the slaves, he goes on to suggest that probably it was written by a newspaper reporter, because he finds the whole theory stated in a newspaper letter written at night after my return to the fort.
The whole matter of the interview with the flag of truce officer was the common talk of all, and the reporter was writing the current news.
Yet Mr. Hay
suggests it might have come from an “imaginative staff officer.”
Why “a staff officer” ? Mr. Hay
, this was a matter of the laws of war. As the general was supposed to have some knowledge upon that subject, why didn't you state in your “History” that you thought it probable the general arrived at such a conclusion of law rather than it should have originated with an “imaginative staff officer” or be contributed as a “handy expedient by the busy brain of a newspaper reporter” ?
If Mr. Hay
had desired to write “History” and not simply to make a book suggesting “historical riddles,” he could easily have ascertained regarding the matter by writing a simple note either to Major Carey
, who is an honored citizen of Richmond, Va.
, or to his associates bearing that flag, or to myself.
If he had put the question to me I should have answered: “A poor thing, sir, but mine own.”
If he had inquired of Major Carey
, that gentleman would have answered that “contraband” was the ground upon which I refused to release Mallory
's slaves and that we then discussed the whole question together.
, read this:--
If Mr. Hay
had looked in the New York Tribune
, of which he was once editor, he would have found a letter written that day at Fortress Monroe
, after I had my interview with Major Carey
, and in that letter he would have read the following:--
Three slaves, the property of Colonel Mallory, commander of the rebel forces near Hampton, were brought in by our picket guard yesterday.
They reported that they were about to be sent South, and hence sought protection.
Major Carey came in with a flag of truce and claimed their rendition under the fugitive slave law, and was informed by General Butler that under the peculiar circumstances he considered the fugitives contraband of war, and had set them to work inside the fortress.
, you do not speak of anybody who ever said anything to the contrary of the “contraband” thought being mine: why not, if you ever heard anything to the contrary?
Upon the whole do you not think this exhibition of facts which I have made as to the manner of your writing “History” shows that you wrote very carelessly and negligently your “History” of Abraham Lincoln
If it is all written like this specimen,--for I have not read it all because I know more about Abraham Lincoln
than you ever did,--God help poor Lincoln
's memory thus to go down to posterity.
You can't weigh a load of hay with fish scales, you know.
Speaking of phrases, they will stick to the man they belong to. This one will stick to me in spite of all efforts to the contrary, and I know of another phrase which will stick to you in spite of all yours, because no Christian gentleman will ever claim it, and no man of good literary taste will ever permit it to be ascribed to him. The phrase I refer to is the only thing that ever made your poem “Little Breeches” famous, while making, perhaps, its author infamous:--
Is a derned sight better business
Than loafing around The Throne.
I made requisition on General Scott
for horses, for artillery, for wagons, and for tents and camp equipage, as my command was largely unprovided for in that regard.
At last I sent my brother to Washington
to get authority to buy some.
He got it, and went to Baltimore
and bought one hundred and twenty-five very good horses.
Meanwhile I had sent to my home for nine horses of my own, which were coming as soon as they could be got there.
Orders were left that the horses obtained by my brother should be sent on after him to Fortress Monroe
; but he was not an old campaigner, and did not know that there were as many horse thieves in the army as there were out of it. The next day, his horses not coming, he went to see what the matter was, and found that one hundred and odd had been taken to Washington
, so it was very lucky that mine from home had not got there.
This loss of horses for my artillery was of very serious consequence to me and a serious loss to the country.
If I could have had a few horses so that I could have mounted my artillery and picked out a few of my best soldiers
for cavalry under an experienced cavalry officer, and thus have had the ground reconnoitred and some guns served to meet the enemy's guns at the time of the attack on Big Bethel, that encounter would have resulted in an entirely different way and in perfectly certain victory for the United States troops.
There was a point nine miles from the fort and on the road leading from Hampton
, which I learned the rebels intended to entrench and hold, because they expected a move towards Richmond
to be made very soon.
The insane cry of “On to Richmond
” had been continually sounded by Mr. Greeley
and his coadjutors.
After carefully reconnoitring the position, I concluded upon an attack.
A creek crossed the road close by the church known as the Bethel.
The bridge over this creek was attempted to be commanded by a slight fortification some half a cannon-shot distance beyond.
Col. D. H. Hill
, of North Carolina
, held it with five hundred men. Our negro scouts reported them two thousand in number, and they really thought there were as many as that, for a negro scout had to be a veteran in the war before he learned that two hundred men were not a thousand, and that five hundred were not two thousand.
So upon the point of numbers I was satisfied; and I was further convinced that there were no more than one thousand in Yorktown
, that might possibly come to Bethel
, as they afterwards did.
After the most careful and thorough preparation, and a personal reconnoissance of the lay of the country by Major Winthrop
, I came to the conclusion to attempt to take this post, and I drew up with his aid the following order for the detail of the movement :--
A regiment or battalion to march from Newport News, and a regiment to march from Camp Hamilton,--Duryea's. Each will be supported by sufficient reserves under arms in camp, and with advanced guards out on the road of march.
Duryea to push out two picket posts at 10 P. M.; one two and a half miles beyond Hampton, on the county road, but not so far as to alarm the enemy.
This is important.
Second picket half as far as the first.
Both pickets to keep as much out of sight as possible.
No one whatever to be allowed to pass out through their lines.
Persons to be allowed to pass inward toward Hampton, unless it appears that they intend to go roundabout and dodge through to the front.
At 12, midnight, Colonel Duryea will march his regiment, with fifteen round cartridges, on the county road towards Little Bethel.
Scows will be provided to ferry them across Hampton Creek.
March to be rapid, but not hurried.
A howitzer with canister and shrapnel to go.
A wagon with planks and material to repair the Newmarket bridge.
Duryea to have the two hundred rifles.
He will pick the men to whom to entrust them.
Rocket to be thrown up from Newport News.
Notify Commodore Pendergrast of this to prevent general alarm.
Newport News movement to be made somewhat later, as the distance is less.
If we find the enemy and surprise them, men will fire one volley, if desirable, not reload, and go ahead with the bayonet.
As the attack is to be by night, or dusk of morning, and in two detachments, our people should have some token, say a white rag (or dirty white rag) on the left arm.
Perhaps the detachments who are to do the job should be smaller than a regiment, three hundred or five hundred, as the right and left of the attack would be more easily handled.
If we bag the Little Bethel men, push on to Big Bethel, and similarly bag them.
Burn both the Bethels, or blow up if brick.
To protect our rear in case we take the field-pieces, and the enemy should march his main body (if he has any) to recover them, it would be well to have a squad of competent artillerists, regular or other, to handle the captured guns on the retirement of our main body.
Also spikes to spike them if retaken.
George Scott to have a shooting iron.
Perhaps Duryea's men would be awkward with a new arm in a night or early dawn attack, where there will be little marksman duty to perform.
Most of the work will be done with the bayonet, and they are already handy with the old ones.
There was a small negro church called Little Bethel which stood in advance of Great Bethel a short distance.
That was in no way fortified, and sheltered a few men.
I could not go with the command myself and it was not proper that I should; but I selected as commander my officer next in rank, General Pierce
, of Massachusetts
I very much wished to devolve the command on Colonel Phelps
as certainly the more competent officer, but there were unfortunately one or two colonels outranking
him that were no more qualified than General Pierce
, and I did not like to do these officers an apparent injustice.
Besides I did not deem the enterprise at all difficult.
Newport News was nearer Bethel
, and my proposition was that the regiment there should start later than the two regiments from Camp Hamilton, and that at a well-known junction of the road they should meet, advance as fast as possible, capture Little Bethel, which could easily be done, and then all make an assault at daylight upon the entrenchments at Great Bethel.
To be sure of having the march properly timed, I ordered the signal to be given at Newport News.
There were four very small howitzers which were to be drawn by the men, for want of horses to take up larger guns.
With six of our men to one of the enemy I could not conceive how there could be any possibility of not marching at once over the works; and if the troops had marched steadily forward the rebels would not have stayed a minute.
Everything was utterly mismanaged.
When the troops got out four or five miles to the junction where the regiments were to meet, it being early dawn and the officers being very much scared, Colonel Bendix
mistook the colonels and staff of the other regiment for a body of cavalry, and fired upon them.
The fire was returned; and by that performance we not only lost more men than were lost in the battle, but also ended all chance for a surprise.
The two regiments marched forward, the main force remaining behind.
took Little Bethel, which had been abandoned.
With two hundred rifle-men supporting Greble
and his cannon, Duryea
went forward with his Zouaves to a piece of timber, and opened fire in answer to the enemy's artillery.
advanced his guns within three hundred yards of the enemy's battery.
He was pretty soon left by the Zouaves, who took shelter in the woods.
That was no harm, as nobody came out from the entrenchments to disturb him. He silenced one of the enemy's guns, and substantially all of them, when by the last discharge of a gun by the enemy he was instantly killed.
From that time there did not seem to be a head more than a cabbage head to undertake to do anything, except it might be Winthrop
held his position an hour and a half, while the main body of the troops stood about a half mile from his position
waiting for the officers to form a plan of battle.
They carefully disobeyed orders, which were, as has been seen, to go right ahead with fixed bayonets and fire but one shot, and they did not do even that.
If they had only marched steadily forward, as I have said before, the enemy would have fled.
The plan that they at last agreed upon was well enough, only an exceedingly contrary one.
They decided not to attack the rebel position in front, but to endeavor to go around it. Therefore it was agreed that Duryea
should hold his place where it was, in apparent support of Greble
's battery; that Colonel Townsend
should march obliquely to the left beyond the woods so that he might strike the Yorktown
road and attack the enemy in his rear and cut him off from Yorktown
; that at the same time Bendix
should march by his flank obliquely to the right and then go across a little stream easily fordable, and form a junction with Townsend
in the rear of the enemy's entrenchments; and that would result either in the enemy taking flight or being captured.
But as Townsend
moved up, a portion of his command got a little ahead of him on the other side of a stone wall.
When he saw them, he took them for a body of the enemy trying to flank him, and at once concluded to retire.
He did retire, leaving Winthrop
near the fort in expectation of instant victory.
did not know that the order had been given for the retirement of Townsend
sprang upon a log to take a view of the situation, and see how matters stood.
He was supported by one private.
All the rest of his support had retired under orders.
As he stood up in full view, a rifle shot from the enemy killed him instantly.
were trying to pass to the left of the enemy's entrenchments to be ready to spring upon them when Townsend
had got to his position; and that was all that was done.
A council was called and all the colonels but Duryea
voted to retire, and Pierce
gave the order.
The ground it was put upon was that the troops with long marching were hungry.
They had actually marched eleven miles; and if Pierce
had given the order for them to sit down and take lunch, the enemy would have run away (as is now known they did do), because they would have supposed we had come to stay.
A few volunteers headed by Lieutenant-Colonel
remained on the field until they could pick up all the wounded.
They brought off Greble
's gun, and then had to drag the wounded in wagons nine miles.
Upon the return to the fort the stories that were brought back were sufficient evidence of the great alarm.
said that there were between four and five thousand of the enemy.
These statements will perhaps be better summed up in the way they finally got into the Northern
press, through a communication addressed to me:--
Men cannot be required to stand in front of a rampart thirty feet high, before the muzzles of mounted guns, loaded with grape and canister and musket balls, doing nothing.
When they are commanded to march through fire and reach the ditch, they must be provided with the means to cross it, or jump into it, and sticking their bayonets into the slope of the scarp, form with them ladders by means of which the more active can mount the parapet.
But before men are sent into a position — recollecting that every ditch will be swept by a flank fire — they must not only be instructed in their duties, but supported by a steady fire upon the enemy.
As a specimen of the stories reported back, I have a vivid memory of an extraordinary one told me by one of the bravest young men I ever knew.
He was then not even a private in the army, but he begged of me the privilege of going with the expedition and carrying a musket.
His father was a warm friend of mine and I took his son in my charge when I first started, using him as a sort of private secretary to take care of my papers and copy some of them.
I afterwards appointed.
him a lieutenant when I raised my troops for the New Orleans expedition.
He went down there with me, became a very efficient officer, distinguished for bravery and dash, and in two years was made a brigadier-general for his defence of one of the forts on the Mississippi River
against a very superior force of the enemy.
He was avery level-headed gentleman in every particular.
I think I left him in the Department of the Gulf as a lieutenant-colonel.
There his promotions were got under other commanders.
Yet in the evening of that day at Great Bethel, after I had spent several hours hearing all sorts of stories, he came into my office and said:--
“General, do you want me to tell you anything of the fight up at Great Bethel?”
“Yes, I do,” said I; “I have heard nothing but the account of men who seem to have been frightened almost to death.
I don't believe you were.”
“But I was, General, yet I think I can tell you what I saw. I cannot tell you anything about the two regiments shooting at each other going up, because I was not there at that time; I was with Duryea
Well, we took Little Bethel, and that was not anything to take; the rebels had run away.
Then we marched up into the woods to support Greble
's battery, and we remained there a while.
As we came up to the woods the enemy began to fire at us and the balls at first went over our heads into the trees.
Well, we could have stood that, but, General, they fired ‘rotten balls.’
“You mean shells, I suppose?”
“Well, yes; that is what they told me afterwards they were; but they would strike a tree and burst, and the pieces would drop around among us. I guess if they had been regular balls the men would have stood it, but they broke and scattered to the woods.
It seemed as if they might as well scatter as anyway; because there was nobody came out of the fort at us.”
“Well,” said I, “I am glad to see a man who got near enough to see what the fort was.”
“It was a very large fort, I should think some thirteen feet high, and they had mounted on it some fifteen or twenty guns.
There was a ditch in the front, and if we had got up to it it would have been impossible for us to have climbed up so as to get in it.”
“Do you know anybody that got nearer to it than you?”
“No; there were some as near.
went clear up farther than any of us, and then he. went back to the main body of the troops.”
That was the least exaggerated report that I got of the fort.
Some reported as many as thirty guns.
As a matter of fact, there were three six-pounder field-pieces, and the fortification was so low that they had to dig an excavation to let the wheels down so as to bring the top of the parapet above the top of the gun carriages so as to protect them from our fire.
Afterwards I rode my horse at full trot over those thirteen feet high parapets.
I sent quite early in the evening to have George Scott
, who was to have a “shooting iron” and accompany Winthrop
, and found him
mourning bitterly for his loss.
I asked him if he was afraid to go up that night to Big Bethel and see who were there and how many there were.
He said he would go up, and I gave him a light basket containing some restoratives and bandages if he should find any wounded.
He started with alacrity.
I told him to get back as soon as he could, and to have me called at whatever hour of night.
Returning before daybreak he reported to me, and from the nature of the report, I had no doubt of its truth.
He had gone on to the field, and had looked around in the woods to see if he could find any wounded or dead men, but found none.
He crept up carefully near the works and listened to hear any noise of a sentinel or anybody.
Not hearing anything, he cautiously advanced until he got up to the breastwork, and then, after carefully looking it over, he went into the work, and found not one soul there.
The enemy had retired, and nobody to this day, as far as I can ascertain, knows whether the rebels went before our men did or afterwards.
It may be worthy of note that the same thing happened at the battle near Manassas Junction
, known as the battle of Bull Run
; after the fight both armies ran away, so that there was no armed force on the battle field, as I have been informed, and correctly, I believe.
It will be seen that the affair at Bethel
was simply a skirmish, and not even a respectable one at that, either in the vigor of the attack or in the loss of men. We lost quite as many men by the fire of Colonel Bendix
upon Colonel Townsend
's regiment of foot, mistaking it for cavalry, as we lost altogether at Bethel
When the plan of the expedition became fully known and the condition of the place which was to be attacked was ascertained, nobody criticised the movement, as there were two regiments1
to go into the fight with a brigadier-general in command.
I had but one brigadier-general
, General Pierce
, and I had to give him the command.
Yet while no blame could seem to attach to me, a senseless cry went out against me, and it almost cost me my confirmation in the Senate.
Of course every Democrat voted against me, and so did some of the Republicans, for various reasons.
I suppose I should have failed of confirmation if Colonel Baker
, then senator from Oregon
, who had been detailed to do duty with me at Fortress Monroe
, had not been in his seat and explained the
senselessness of the clamor.
But one senator from my own State voted for me, the other, the senior senator
, voting against me because of my difference with Governor Andrew
on the slave question.
In the meantime neither horses nor artillery came.
I did, however, get a very valuable reinforcement of a California regiment and a half, at the head of which was Colonel Baker
, who had had some experience in Mexico
as an officer.
We agreed to attempt, as soon as our horses and artillery should come, an expedition that would reflect credit on both of us, and we determined that neither should blame the other if it failed, because both would go together.
I asked, on the 23d of May, for a few artillery and cavalry horses with their equipments.
These were not received from Washington
until July 21, and then only after every possible exertion on my part even to the extent, as we have seen, of causing them to be bought by my own agent and having them brought on to Washington
This was not negligence, as I at first supposed, but studied unjust treatment.
I should not venture to say this did I not have it in a letter from a man in Washington
who knew everything that was done about army headquarters,--a bold soldier, an officer, a general.
As he is yet alive I do not give his name; but the letter has been published now more than a quarter of a century and no man has ever dared to question it. It is as follows:--
June 8th I received your letter and despatch, and, contrary to your orders, I read both to the President, under the seal of confidence, however.
I have told him that------would never let you have any troops to make any great blow, and I read the despatch to show that I understood my man. He intended to treat you as he did------, and as he has always treated those whom he knew would be effective if he gave them the means, retaining everything in his own power and under his own immediate control, so as to monopolize all the reputation to be made.
I have been a little afraid lest you might attempt more than your means justified, under the impression that you would otherwise disappoint, the country.
But I am pleased to see that you have not made this mistake.
You must work on patiently till you feel yourself able to do the work you attempt, and not play into your enemies' hands, or those of the miserable do-nothings here, by attempting more than in your cool judgment the force you have can effect.
You will gradually get the means, and then you may make an effective blow.
Unfortunately, indeed, the difficulties increase as your force increases, if not more rapidly.
We have forty
thousand men, I believe, and provisions and transportation enough to take them to Richmond any day, and yet our lines do not extend five miles into Virginia, where there are not, in my opinion, men enough to oppose the march of half the number to Richmond.
Old------is at------with twenty thousand men, and is moving as cautiously towards the Potomac as if the banks were commanded by an army of Bonaparte's best legions, instead of a mob, composed for the most part of men who will only wait for an opportunity to desert a flag they detest.
This war will last forever if something does not happen to unseat old------.------in the West, with sixty thousand men under canvas, has not made a movement except let a few regiments march up the Baltimore & Ohio railroad, at the urgent solicitations of the people.
So we go. Congress will probably catch us without our having performed any service worthy of the great force we have under pay.
I grumble this way all the time, and to everybody, in the hope that I may contribute to push on the column.
I am very much in hopes we shall be pushed into action by the indignation of the people, if not by our own sense of what is due to the cause we have taken in hand.
On the day that I received my horses and artillery and was preparing to start on our expedition, the battle of Bull Run
I had ascertained before, from a private source, that I was not to have any aid before the battle of Bull Run
, and that some of my troops were to be withdrawn.
Immediately after that battle, which was predestined to disaster on our side, as I shall take leave to make plain hereafter, an order came on the 24th of July that all my effective forces should be removed to Baltimore
together with Colonel Baker
They had become so frightened at Washington
that they supposed the secessionists of Baltimore
would rise, while there was no more danger of it than there was of an outbreak at Boston
In fact, there never was at any time during the war so much of an outbreak at Baltimore
as there was at Boston
when the draft riots occurred; and that Boston
outbreak was put down by a young officer of mine, Lieutenant Carruth
, with two pieces of artillery, served by men who had not yet been mustered into service.
Of course this move of Scott
ended all hope or expectation that anything further would be allowed to be done at Fortress Monroe
To make it sure that nothing more would be done, as Scott
thought, he soon afterward sent a man to relieve me from command that could not do anything but simply occupy the position of commander
of that department, and leave me to do the work, and restrain me from doing anything.
's condition and Scott
's knowledge of it will appear in the following correspondence:--
There had been great complaint in the New York Times
that General Wool
had not been given some place where his great experience would have a fair chance to benefit the country.
It was argued by the Times
in an editorial after the battle of Bull Run
, that there should be a dictator who should take Lincoln
's place and carry on the war, and that George Law should be that dictator.
As this was not done at once, there was a cry that the great State of New York
should have another major-general in the army.
It was urged that there was in New York a major-general of the regular army--General Wool
--who had lived for a great many years in a state of retiracy, and that he should have a command in the army suited to his rank, and that it was the duty of the President
to have him assigned to such command.
Now, the President
well knew that General Wool
could not do anything, simply because he was too old and infirm, a fact that he knew as well as anybody.
It was evident, too, from Scott
's letter that he also knew it, because he wrote Wool
telling him that if his health would allow it, it would be desirable that he should be sent to Fortress Monroe
came there; but there was no order to relieve me, and I was not at liberty to leave the department.
got there on the 17th of August, and I turned over the command to him. There was nothing I could complain of. A very much older soldier, and a very efficient military officer when he was younger, was ordered to command in my department; and although he had been assigned only to the Department of South Eastern Virginia
, yet I supposed that meant the whole Department of Virginia and North Carolina.
At any rate, I did not choose to struggle on that point, and so I turned over the command to him, using these words:--“No personal feelings of regret intrudes itself at the change in the command of the department, by which our cause acquires the services in the field of the veteran general commanding, in whose abilities, experience, and devotion to the flag, the whole country places the most explicit reliance, and under whose guidance and command, all of us, and none more than your late commander
, are proud to serve.”
Thereupon General Wool
, who was lieutenant-general by brevet, immediately put me in command of all the troops in the department except the regulars
To show what General Wool
thought as to my not having done any more, I take leave to transcribe his first letter to General Scott
, August 24, three days after he was put in command:--
My friends, a great many of them, were very much disturbed by this position of things.
They said that this action of General Scott
was intended to slight me; that I was made second in command, and that I ought to resign at once and go home, and the people would set it all right; that Scott
had never blamed me for the reverse of even a platoon under my command except at Bethel
, and that there the movement was well planned and failed only because it had to be carried out by somebody else than myself, so that at any rate I was not to blame.
I told all my friends that I did not feel aggrieved at all; that I would beat Scott
at his own game, as indeed I was already prepared to do; that he had sent Wool
down without any instructions; that Wool
could not go anywhere or do anything; that Wool
did not like Scott
any better than Scott
did me; that Wool
wanted all the work done by some one else while he had a nice place in the camp, and I wanted to do all the work I could do and have somebody else take the responsibility.
I had been watching the building of Fort Hatteras and Fort Clark
I had had some loyal North Carolinians for many weeks in the forts at work, and I proposed, as soon as I could, to take the forts, for they were very important.
But it would be of no more use for me to ask Scott
for any troops with which to do it than it would be to attempt to fly. No, he would not even let me take the troops I had or any part of them.
Therefore, as soon as General Wool
got fairly in his saddle, I explained to him these matters about the forts at Hatteras
, and the
great necessity of taking them.
Now he was an officer in the regular army and I knew would never attempt such an expedition without a great many men with him; it must be a great expedition.
Therefore I said nothing to him about how many men I thought it would need.
I assured him, however, that there could be no danger of any attack either upon Newport News or Fortress Monroe
, because I had sent up a balloon over a thousand feet so as to examine the whole country round about, and found that Magruder
had retired to Bethel
with his troops, and given up his expedition against Newport News.
This, by the way, was the first balloon reconnoissance of the war.
I also told Wool
that in his assignment Scott
did not mean to let him do anything any more than he did me. I set out to him the exact condition of things in regard to Hatteras
, and informed him that the navy was very anxious to make the attack, and if it were done while he was in command of that department, it would result in great glory to him as the first considerable success of the war. After my consultation with him, an order was drawn as follows, which he signed:--
Armed with the order we left Fortress Monroe
at one o'clock on Monday, August 26.
The last ship of our fleet but the Cumberland
arrived at Hatteras
about 4 o'clock on Tuesday afternoon. We went to work landing troops that evening and put on shore all we could, 345, when all our boats became swamped in the surf.
Our flat boat was stove, and also one of the boats from the steamer Pawnee
We therefore found it impracticable to land more troops.
The landing was being covered by the guns of the Monticello
and the Harriet Lane
I was on board the Harriet Lane
directing the landing of the troops by means of signals, and was about landing with them, when the boats were stove.
We were prevented from further attempts at landing by the rising of the wind and sea.
In the meantime the fleet had opened its fire upon the nearest fort, which was finally silenced and its flag struck.
No firing was opened upon our troops from the other fort, and its flag was also struck.
Supposing this to be a signal for surrender, Colonel Weber
, who was in command on shore, advanced his troops up the beach.
By my direction the Harriet Lane
was trying to cross the bar so as to get in the smooth water of the inlet, when the other fort opened fire upon the Monticello
, which had proceeded in advance of us.
Early the next morning the Harriet Lane
ran in shore for the purpose of covering any attack upon the troops.
At the same time a large steamer was observed coming down the sound.
She was loaded with reinforcements of the enemy, but she was prevented from landing.
At eight o'clock the fleet opened fire on the forts again, the flag-ship being anchored as near as the depth of water allowed and the other ships coming gallantly into action.
Meanwhile I went with the Fanny
over the bar into the inlet.
As the Fanny
rounded in over the bar, the rebel steamer Winslow
went up the channel having on board a large number of rebel troops, which
she had not been able to land.
We threw a shot at her from the Fanny
, but she proved to be out of range.
I then sent Lieutenant Crosby
on shore to demand the meaning of the white flag which had been hoisted.
The boat soon returned, bringing the following communication from Samuel Barron
, late captain
in the United States Navy:--
A verbal communication also was sent by Barron
stating that he had 615 men in the fort and one thousand more within an hour's call, but that he was anxious to spare the effusion of blood.
To both the written and verbal communications I made reply as follows, and sent it by Lieutenant Crosby
Benj. F. Butler, Major-General U. S. Army, commanding, in reply to the communication of Samuel Barron, commanding forces at Fort Hatteras, cannot admit the terms proposed.
The terms offered are these: Full capitulation; the officers and men to be treated as prisoners of war. No other terms admissible.
Commanding officers to meet on board flag-ship Minnesota to arrange details.
After waiting three quarters of an hour Lieutenant Crosby
returned, bringing with him Captain Barron
, Major Andrews
, and Colonel Martin
, of the rebel forces.
Upon being received on board the tug Fanny
, they informed me that they had accepted the terms proposed in my memorandum, and had come to surrender themselves and their command as prisoners of war. I informed them that inasmuch as the expedition was a combined one of the army and navy, the surrender must be made on board the flag-ship to Flag-Officer Stringham
as well as to myself.
They went on board the Minnesota
, and the capitulation was agreed to.
I will mention in this connection that at the moment that my terms of capitulation were under consideration by the enemy, the
, crowded with troops, had grounded upon the bar; but by the active and judicious exertions of Commander Stellwagen
she was got off after some delay.
At the same time the Harriet Lane
, in attempting to enter over the bar, had grounded and remained fast.
Both were under the guns of the fort.
This to me was a moment of the greatest anxiety.
By these accidents a valuable ship of war, and a transport steamer, with a large portion of my troops,were within the power of the enemy.
I had demanded the strongest terms, which he was then considering.
He might refuse, and, seeing our disadvantage, renew the action.
But I determined not to abate a tittle of what I believed to be due to the dignity of the government, nor even to give an official title to the officer in command of the rebels.
Besides, my tug was in the inlet, and at least I could carry on the engagement with my two rifled six-pounders, well supplied with Sawyer
The harm to the enemy by this capture was very great.
We had 715 prisoners, one thousand stand of arms, thirty pieces of cannon, one ten-inch columbiad, a prize brig loaded with cotton, a sloop loaded with provisions and stores, two light boats, a schooner in ballast, five stand of colors, and 150 bags of coffee.
But this was not all the damage inflicted upon the enemy.
As long as we kept control of the sea, we could hold that post for all time with a small force.
That was exactly what we did do, and with a very small force — less than one thousand men. By so doing we controlled the whole coast of North
and South Carolina
in the sounds, and held the water communication from Norfolk
to Beaufort, South Carolina
's expedition afterwards never could have been sent out had we not held Hatteras
The wonderful stupidity at Washington
desired Hatteras Inlet stopped up, so that nothing could get into or out of it. So the fleet had supplied itself with two sand-laden schooners to sink in the inlet, where the sands floating around would have soon made dry land.
When I came there I saw the importance not only of having the inlet open but of guarding and defending it. I had positive orders from Washington
to sink the sand vessels.
With my usual “hazardous bravado” I came to the conclusion to disobey orders and not sink the vessels.
I could do that with some safety, I thought, provided
I got to Washington
and carried the news of the capture myself.
Accordingly I had the wounded placed on board the transport steamer Adelaide
, and had this vessel detached by leave of Flag-Officer Stringham
of the navy,--a gallant officer, an energetic man, and a thorough gentleman, who had shown great capability and courage in that expedition, and who was rewarded for it soon after by being detached from his command and sent up to the Charlestown Navy Yard
, near Boston
, to superintend the repairing of hulks.
He was to remain at Hatteras
with the fleet to supply and defend the fort, until he should hear from me; and so I steamed night and day to Fortress Monroe
Reporting to General Wool
, I got leave immediately to go to Washington
, or, as he expressed it, he sent me to Washington
to report the matter, he agreeing with me that it was very necessary to hold Fort Hatteras and keep the inlet open.
I went up the bay to Annapolis
and left the wounded there, arriving there at a late hour in the evening.
I immediately made requisition for a train to take myself and staff to Washington
, and we started at eleven o'clock at night.
When we reached the junction of the Elkton Railroad with the Baltimore
, nineteen miles from Washington
, I was informed that I could go no further that night.
I asked why not, and the officer in charge said that they had no train in which to send me.
“I have a train of my own to go with,” I replied.
“Well,” said he, “I have been talking with your engineer, and he says it is dangerous to go.”
“Well, I hope you haven't frightened him so he won't go,” I replied.
Going to the engineer I said: “Won't you go to Washington
“If you say I shall go, I shall go, General, but it is dangerous.”
“Oh, well,” I said, “I have not come here for safety.
Why is it dangerous?”
He said that it was because there was only one track open, and there might be freight trains coming out of Washington
, and that we might run into them, as they started some time about midnight.
“Well,” I said, “we will detach all the cars and I will go with you on the engine;” and jumping on the engine, with one member of my staff, the rest remaining behind as there was no room for them, I said: “Let her go.”
“Shall we go slow,” said he, “so that we shall find out when a train is coming before we reach it, in time to back out?”
“ With only your engine you ought to back out very quickly.”
“Oh, well,” said he, “but I want your directions.”
“Very well; let her go as fast as she can go.”
“Then,” he says, “hold on to your cap, General,” and we went that nineteen miles in forty minutes, and got into the depot at Washington
five minutes before any train started out.
Dropping a twenty-dollar gold piece in the hands of the engineer, I got off, woke a sleeping negro in a carriage, and told him to drive up to Postmaster-General Blair
's house, opposite the White House
, as fast as he could.
As I drove up I saw Mr. Blair
and the Assistant Secretary of the Navy
, Mr. Fox
, sitting together in his study.
I went in. Fox
knew that I had gone on the expedition to Hatteras
, for it was one in which he was much interested.
When he saw me he cried out: “Where from?”
“ Direct from Hatteras
I stated the result of the expedition.
He was very much elated, and asked me to go right over and tell the President
“We ought not to do that,” said I, “and get him up at this time of night.
Let him sleep.”
“He will sleep enough better for it; so let us go and wake him up.”
We went over to the White House
and got the watchman up. It took us some fifteen minutes to do it, and I remember remarking to Fox
that if I was on the other side I could have come here and captured the President
and carried him off. Then we went up into the
The President was called, and when our errand was hinted to him he immediately came in in his night shirt.
Everybody knows how tall Lincoln
was, and he seemed very much taller in that garment; and Fox
was about five feet nothing.
In a few hurried words, without waiting for any forms or ceremonies, Fox
communicated the news, and then he and Lincoln
fell into each other's arms.
That is, Fox
put his arms around Lincoln
about as high as his hips, and Lincoln
reached down over him so that his arms were pretty near the floor apparently, and thus holding each other they flew around the room once or twice, and the night shirt was considerably agitated.
The commanding general
was entirely overcome by the scene, and lying back on the sofa roared with the most irresistible merriment.
It was the first considerable success that the navy had anything to do with up to that time, or, indeed, the army either, except at Baltimore
The President shook me very warmly by the hand, and when I ventured to speak about what I had not done, he said: “You have done all right, you have done all right.
Come to-morrow at ten o'clock and we will have a Cabinet meeting over it.”
I retired, and at ten o'clock the next morning I made my report to the President
in Cabinet meeting.
Among those present was General McClellan
, whom I then saw for the first time.
I explained the whole situation, giving reasons why I had not obeyed orders and stopped up Hatteras Inlet, and also stating the necessity for holding Fort Hatteras.
On the next day I had the pleasure to report to my chief, General Wool
, whom I never saw as such afterwards, that the Cabinet
had voted unanimously that he should hold Fort Hatteras and Hatteras Inlet.
I had opened the way through Annapolis
for the troops to save the capital; I had fulfilled my mission at Fortress Monroe
; and by taking Hatteras
I had atoned for capturing Baltimore
and wiped out Big Bethel, all in a campaign of four months and fifteen days, besides showing the administration and the country the best way out of the slavery question.
In all this time nobody else had done anything except to get soundly thrashed at Bull Run
Therefore I asked the President
, as I had not been home since I left there on the 16th of April, if he would be kind enough to relieve me and
allow me to go home.
His farewell when he shook my hand was characteristic:--
“ You have a right to go home, General, for a little rest, but study out another job for yourself.”
I may truthfully say, with pride and gratitude, that my road home was an ovation, but for a while my position was an extremely annoying one. Four months and a half before, the young lawyer had left Boston
where he could go anywhere and everywhere and not be disturbed by anybody.
The general now came back, and was not allowed to go anywhere or do anything without somebody interfering with him and insisting upon his being here or going there, with an enormous quantity of stuffing and feasting.
It was so sudden a change from perfect freedom to a perfect slavery of kindness — from taking his constitutional walk in the morning any and everywhere, to not being able to go anywhere without a carriage, because he could not go through the streets for the multitude of hand shakings and greetings that he had to undergo — that it was hardly enjoyable.
It will serve, I hope, some future student of the art of carrying on war with volunteer troops,--and I am inclined to think that they are the only troops that we will use in large numbers in the future, on this side of the Atlantic
at least,--if we examine some of the causes of the nation's failure at the battle of Bull Run
, which had greater results and a more substantial effect on the country than any other in the war, except, perhaps, the battle of Gettysburg
The battle ought not to have been fought at that time by any officer.
It was a predestined and foredoomed defeat.
It was fought under every condition, of difficulty and discouragement with which it was possible to surround a battle.
It was urged on in a manner and under an influence disgraceful to the common sense of mankind.
The New York Tribune
set up a clamor day by day, which had no foundation save in the half-addled brain of its editor, a man who had not strength enough to stand a political defeat in after years without going idiotically insane.
His cry of “On to Richmond
” was repeated by other newspapers, and in this way a great pressure was brought to bear upon the Cabinet
, to which they more or less reluctantly yielded.
, too, was practically about to retire and give way to some younger general as commander of the Army of the Potomac, and
practically as commander-in-chief.
He saw in the movement towards Richmond
the last chance of having any fighting done under his command; and as he wished to go out in a blaze of glory, he consented to it.
It is but fair to McDowell
to say that he was reluctant to fight the battle.
But he was urged on to fight it, as is shown by his report, for the very reason that he should not have fought it. He says:--
I am somewhat embarrassed by the inability of the troops to take care of enough of their rations to make them last the time they should, and by the expiration of the term of service of many of them.
The Fourth Pennsylvania goes out to-day, and others succeed rapidly.
I have made a request to the regiment that they remain a few days longer, but do not hope for much success.
In a few days I shall lose many thousands of the best of this force.
It is made very clear that for those very reasons he should not have fought the battle then.
Substantially all his troops were going home soon and would not fight.
They had been out for their three months, as they had engaged to be, and like schoolboys they were notching the days on a stick when they would go home.
was a captain three months before.
He had had no experience in fighting troops.
He was a brave man, but that was the last time he would get a chance to fight there at the head of the Army of the Potomac.
He speaks in that report of the men being well disciplined.
An older general than he, I venture to disagree with him. Troops do not get disciplined in ninety days, especially if that is to be their term of service.
There are two conditions under which fresh troops, new troops, and especially volunteer troops,will fight well.
The first is: When they are brought into the field for the first time and know nothing about the meeting; when they think that a regiment cut to pieces is not more than one third left alive, and when they really think they are to fight up to about that point.
Under such circumstances they will fight well even if they hardly know enough of the school of the soldier to load their muskets rightly.
When in the course of conversation I have stated to some officers with what readiness new volunteers go into action if called upon to
act at once, I have had occasional doubt expressed, the doubters agreeing that they knew nothing on the subject.
This has led me to examine the matter with considerable care, and I am confirmed in my opinion by the action of raw troops in several instances from my personal knowledge.
But I think one of the very best illustrations I can give of the action of raw troops is in the case of a single Maine
regiment, the First Maine Heavy Artillery, afterwards Eighteenth Maine.
The regiment was raised and sent to Washington
to guard the forts.
It had never been in the field, nor heard a hostile shot.
It was moved forward as fast as possible and joined Grant
's army the night before the battle of Spottsylvania Court House
It went in eighteen hundred strong, and when it came out it was with a loss of four hundred and eighty-one killed and wounded, twelve of whom were officers, and five missing.
They were put into several battles, including Cold Harbor, down to the time of the crossing of the James
, June 12.
On the 18th of July, having about twelve hundred men fit for duty, it was ordered to make a charge in double rank, and came out losing six hundred and thirty-two killed and wounded, thirteen officers being killed and twelve others wounded.
And I was told by an officer of that regiment that after that time they would not have assaulted a pig-pen.
The trouble comes when you put volunteers in camp, especially in the face of the enemy, and let them hear camp rumors, camp gossip, camp ghost and scarecrow stories about masked batteries and black horse cavalry.
As if black horse cavalry were any more effective and terrible than white horse or sorrel horse cavalry!
And yet, during our war, the black horsemen were always the ogre of our soldiers.
Nor did the men ever stop to reflect that a masked battery did not do any harm as long as it remained masked, and that when it was unmasked and began to fire it was no worse to encounter than a battery of the same size that had never been masked.
Men so instructed will not fight at all; they are full of all manner of surprises; they will run at nothing and be surprised at everything.
And that was the condition of McDowell
's army as far as the three months men were concerned, and none but the regulars had been in the service more than three months.
The other condition under which men will fight, is after they have been in the service long enough and got sufficiently disciplined to
know how to fight; have had their first scare in a battle, and have learned that a regiment cut to pieces means a regiment that has lost one man in ten.
Then they will fight better and better as long as they remain in the service, if they have proper officers, who treat them kindly and justly.
Then the three months officers were always worse than the men. They were of necessity to be more exposed in action than the men. They generally had good homes and nice places to go home to, and a great many of them would say if they got out of this action they would never get into another.
Then there was another matter: Everywhere among green troops there is a chronic disposition to over-estimate the number of the opposing troops.
The first duty of the commander should be to find out exactly how many troops there are in the bodies opposed to him. It is exceedingly easy to do that, but it was never done in the beginning of the war; and the fearful imaginations of officers multiplied their opponents wonderfully.
We have already seen that at Great Bethel, General Pierce
and his men believed the fortifications, instead of being four were fourteen feet high, that the four guns were twenty, and that the five hundred rebels in the fortification were four or five thousand.
And on the other hand, the rebels believed that the Yankee
force of General Pierce
that they saw was five thousand men, when there were really but eight hundred.
And so at Bull Run
The entire Union force, sick and well, was 35,732 men; whereas there is a printed estimate reported by the Confederate
authority of 54,140.
After the battle, the officers in charge of the prisoners captured by the rebels, having made a calculation by asking the prisoners what regiments or batteries they belonged to, gravely reported the Federal
force on the field that day at 63,000.
And so exactly about everything else.
The total actual loss of the United States troops in killed, wounded, and missing was 1,107.
The total loss on the Confederate
side, as reported by the rebel general, Joe Johnston
, was 1,897.
He naively concludes his report in that regard with the statement that the loss of the enemy could not be ascertained, but must have been four or five thousand.
There was another matter: Both sides left the field, and both sides
in their reports lied about the manner of leaving.
Either side could have pursued the other; certainly the Confederate
troops could have come into Washington
without difficulty if they had chosen to come.
and Bull Run
are alike in another thing: In Bethel
our people retreated because they thought they saw large numbers of reinforcements coming up. At Bull Run
our troops retreated in disorder and gave way because they saw the cars coming in from Harper's Ferry
loaded with Johnston
's troops of the Army of the Shenandoah, and so they gave up all for lost.
And the general idea of the people to this day is that the coming up of Johnston
's army from Harper's Ferry
on the afternoon of the battle as a surprise reinforcement was the cause of the loss of Bull Run
Now, the reports on both sides show that Johnston
at Harper's Ferry
in obedience to an order sent him on the 17th, and that he and all his army got down to Bull Run
on the night of the 19th, and were in front of McDowell
on the 20th; and so far from Joe Johnston
's men coming into the action late on the 21st, and our men running away from them, these men bore substantially the whole brunt of the battle during the day, and lost more than twice as many men as did the rebel Army of the Potomac.
Besides, and in addition to all these disadvantages of the conduct of the battle, Johnston
's force had been allowed by Patterson
to escape him entirely, and Patterson
never thought of following him up. If he had followed him up he could have been in Johnston
's rear or on the left flank of the rebel army at the battle of Bull Run
But what could Patterson
The rebel army had gone away from him, and he did not know they were gone until three days afterwards.
He thought there were thirty-five thousand men before him, when there had been less than nine thousand, and they had gone down to operate on McDowell
The battle of Bull Run
illustrates every vice, weakness, and incapacity of officers and men, who were good and true undoubtedly, but in a condition in which they will never fight.
So bad was it all that one might reverently believe that a special Providence
ordered it, so that slavery might be wiped out. Because if we had beaten at Bull Run
, I have no doubt the whole contest would have been patched up and healed over by concessions to slavery, as nobody in power was ready then for its abolition.