This text is part of:
1 Fritzsche's view that Ar. Ran. 72 implies the previous death (i.e. ante 405) of A. is refuted by Rettig, Symp. pp. 59 ff.
2 See e.g. Zeller, Plato (E.T.) p. 139 n.; Teichmüller, Litt. Fehd. II. 262.
3 See Dümmler, Akademica, p. 40; and the refutation by Vahlen, op. Acad. 1. 482 ff.
4 So I hold with Schleierm., Zeller, I. Bruns, Hahn and others; against Lutosl., Gomperz and Raeder. It is monstrous to assert, as Lutosl. does, “that the date of the Phaedrus as written about 379 B.C. is now quite as well confirmed as the date of the Symp. about 385 B.C.” I agree rather with the view which makes Phaedrus P.'s first publication after he opened his Academy, i.e. circ. 388-6 (a view recently supported in England by E. S. Thompson, Meno xliii ff., and Gifford, Euthyd. 20 ff.). The foll. are some of the parallels: Phaedrus 232 E=Symp. 181 E, 183 E; 234 A=183 E; 234 B=183 C; 250 C=209 E; 251 D (240 C)=215 E, 218 A; 251 A=215 B, 222 A; 252 A= 189 D; 266 A=180 E; 267 A (273 A)=200 A; 272 A=198 D; 276 A=222 A; 276 E=209 B; 278 D=203 E; 279 B=216 D, 215 B.
5 Among those who claim priority for Xenophon are Böckh, Ast, Delbrück, Rettig, Teichmüller, Hug, Dümmler, Pfleiderer; on the other side are C. F. Hermann, I. Bruns, Schenkl, Gomperz. Beside the broader resemblances set forth by Hug, the foll. refs. to echoes may be of interest:— Xen. Plat. i. 1 =178 A, 197 E ii. 23=213 E, 214 A ii. 26 (iv. 24)=185 C, 198 C iv. 14=183 A, 184 B, 179 A iv. 15=178 E, 179 B, 182 C iv. 16=178 E iv. 17=181 E, 183 E iv. 19 (v. 7)=215 A (216 D, 221 D) iv. 23=181 D iv. 25=193 D iv. 28=217 E iv. 47—8=188 D iv. 48=188 D iv. 50=189 A, 197 E Xen. Plat. iv. 53 =219 B v. 1, 7 =218 E (175 E) viii. 1 =218 B (187 D) viii. 8 =219 D viii. 13=184 B viii. 21=214 C viii. 23=183 A (203 B), 172 C viii. 24=217 E, 222 C viii. 31=179 E viii. 38=209 E viii. 32 (iv. 16)=178 E viii. 34 =182 B viii. 35 =179 A The last three parallels are specially interesting, since Xen. ascribes to Pausan. some of the sentiments which Pl. gives to Phaedrus. Possibly (as Hug, Teichm. and others suppose) both writers are indebted to an actual apologia of the real Pausan., which Pl. is handling more freely, Xen. more exactly (cp. I. Bruns, Vorträge, p. 152).
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.
An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.