Why did they bid the priest avoid the dog
and the goat, neither touching them nor naming
them?
Did they loathe the goat's lasciviousness and foul
odour, or did they fear its susceptibility to disease?
For it is thought to be subject to epilepsy beyond all
other animals, and to infect persons who eat it1
or touch it when it is possessed of the disease. The
reason, they say, is the narrowness of the air passages, which are often suddenly contracted; this they
deduce from the thinness of its voice. So also in the
case of men, if they chance to speak during an epileptic fit, the sound they make is very like a bleat.
The dog has, perhaps, less of lasciviousness and
foul odour. Some, however, assert that a dog may not
enter either the Athenian acropolis2 or the island of
Delos3 because of its open mating, as if cattle and
swine and horses mated within the walls of a chamber
[p. 165]
and not openly and without restraint ! For these
persons are ignorant of the true reason : because
the dog is a belligerent creature they exclude it
from inviolable arid holy shrines, thereby offering a
safe place of refuge for suppliants. Accordingly it
is likely that the priest of Jupiter also, since he
is, as it were, the animate embodiment and sacred
image of the god, should be left free as a refuge
for petitioners and suppliants, with no one to hinder
them or to frighten them away. For this reason his
couch was placed in the vestibule of his house, and
anyone who fell at his knees had immunity from beating or chastisement all that day ; and if any prisoner
succeeded in reaching the priest, he was set free,
and his chains they threw outside, not by the doors,
but over the roof. So it would have been of no
avail for him to render himself so gentle and humane,
if a dog had stood before him frightening and keeping away those who had need of a place of refuge.
Nor, in fact, did the men of old think that this
animal was wholly pure, for it was never sacrificed to
any of the Olympian gods ; and when it is sent to the
cross-roads as a supper for the earth-goddess HecatĂȘ,4
it has its due portion among sacrifices that avert and
expiate evil. In Sparta they immolate puppies to the
bloodiest of the gods, Enyalius ; and in Boeotia the
ceremony of public purification is to pass between
the parts of a dog which has been cut in twain. The
Romans themselves, in the month of purification,5 at
the Wolf Festival, which they call the Lupercalia,
sacrifice a dog. Hence it is not out of keeping that
those who have attained to the office of serving the
[p. 167]
highest and purest god should be forbidden to make
a dog their familiar companion and housemate.
1 Contrast Pliny, Natural History, xxviii. 16 (226), who says that goat's meat was given for epilepsy.
2 Cf. Comparison of Demetrius and Antony, chap. iv. (95-97 b); Dionysius of Halicarnassus, De Dinarcho, 3.
3 Cf. Strabo, x. 5. 5, p. 684 (Meineke).
4 Cf. 277 b, 280 c, supra; Life of Romulus, xxi. (31 e).
5 February; cf. 280 b, supra.