previous next


"Victory Organized,"

It was said of Carnot, when France was passing through the most fearful crisis of her history, ‘"He hath organized victory."’ The violent throes of the revolution were still felt Civil war was raging in La Vendee; Royalist factions in the interior and on the frontier were plotting the downfall of the Republic; and, besides these internal dangers, France was threatened with invasion by the armies of Spain, Holland, Sardinia, Prussia, Austria, and England. Yet, in the face of this terrible storm, France triumphed. This was before the genius of Napoleon had developed itself, or he had taken command of an army. The civil war in La Vendee, though conducted by Cathalinean and Charette, at the head of large armies, was checked, and the formidable armies of invasion of combined Europe were driven beyond the Rhine. The report of Carnot, the Minister of War, to the National Convention, showed that France had gained twenty-seven victories, eight of which were in order of battle, 120 combats of inferior importance, 80,000 enemies killed, 91,000 prisoners, 116 fortified places or important cities taken, of which 36 were after being besieged or blockaded, 230 forts or redoubts carried, 3,800 cannons and mortars, 70,000 muskets, 1,400 milliars of powder, and 90 standards. All this had been gained in a campaign of seventeen months. To whom was France indebted for this success? Besides the bravery of her soldiers and the vigilance of her commanders, she chiefly owed her triumphs to the genius and energy of Carnot, who was charged with the organization of her armies and the superintendence of their operations. Her was the National Convention slow to make the declaration which has since become histerical, ‘" General has organized victory."’

With this fact in French-history before them, 1st the confederated States profit, and suitedly resolve to ‘"organize victory."’ No one can doubt that the men who compose the armies of the South are in every respect equal to those who, under the direction of Carnot, the immense armies which threatened France with subjugation. The combined resources of the South to furnish the material as well as men, are even greater than those of France of that day — divided as she was by civil war — her finances deranged, her trade paralyzed, and famine spreading through all her departments. The genius of Carnot summoned science to his aid, and France in herself was found sufficient to furnish the means to meet the tremendous struggle. If saltpetre was required for gunpowder the soil of France was searched, and even the mould of the cellars of Paris was subjected to the analysis of the shemist, to furnish the requisite supply. Our resources are greater than those then possessed by France — the discoveries of science since have been greater. We can, therefore, command greater agencies to our aid. If copper was needed for his cannon, Carnel took the bells of the churches. We are forced to no such alternative. Our mountains abound with iron and copper, the hand of genius and industry need only command a supply. Our resources are immense. What we want is the most efficient military organization, and a great and scientific mind like that of Carnot to superintend it. Possibly we have done all under our present military organization that could have been done. Yet, certainly greater efficiency can be secured. When France entered upon the struggle to which we have referred, she was almost destitute of generals. The bansful effects of the system of the Bourbons, in excluding from position in the army all who were not of the class of the nobles, was severely felt. Excepting LaFayette, Dumouren, and a few others, at the conimencement of her revolution, she was without gen of experience, to take command of the lavies she had ordered. Officers were to be created. Carnot was of the opinion of a certain Athenian General, that ‘"an army of deer commanded by a lion, was better than an army of lions commanded by a deer."’ His penetrating eye searched the obscured rank for talent and courage combined, and promoted it rapidly to the highest grade. The essay of young Hoche on the means of penetrating Belgium, attracted his attention. Carnot exclaimed, ‘"Behold a sergeant of infantry, who will make his way; "’ and in a few months Hoche became Captain, Celonel, General of Brigade, General of Dividen, and General-in-Chief. The time has come when every personal consideration must yield to advance the means for the securement of Southern liberty. Let us more

claims to honor, precedence, or place, founded upon past position or rank under the old Government, be the means of preventing the right man from occupying the right place, whether at the head of a division or as a captain of a company. A man may be able to deliver an eloquent political harangue; yea, be a good stateman, yet have none of the elements requisite to make a good general. France under Carnot, and afterward under Napoleon, abjured all this and sought for victory by organizing for it. Let us of the South be wise to profit by her example, and let every patriotic son of the South be ready to day with Carnot, ‘" Let my reputation perish rather than my country."’

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.

An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.

hide Places (automatically extracted)

View a map of the most frequently mentioned places in this document.

Sort places alphabetically, as they appear on the page, by frequency
Click on a place to search for it in this document.
France (France) (12)
Preussen (1)
Belgium (Belgium) (1)
Austria (Austria) (1)

Download Pleiades ancient places geospacial dataset for this text.

hide People (automatically extracted)
Sort people alphabetically, as they appear on the page, by frequency
Click on a person to search for him/her in this document.
Carnot (10)
Napoleon (2)
Hoche (2)
Paris (1)
hide Display Preferences
Greek Display:
Arabic Display:
View by Default:
Browse Bar: