[
365]
When the “
Marble Faun” was first published the art criticism in it, especially of sculptors and painters who were then living, created a deal of discussion, which has been revived again by the recent centennial celebration.
Hawthorne himself was the most perfect artist of his time as a man of letters, and the judgment of such a person ought to have its value, even when it relates to subjects which are beyond the customary sphere of his investigations, and for which he has not made a serious preparation.
In spite of the adage, “every man to his own trade,” it may be fairly asserted that much of
Hawthorne's art criticism takes rank among the finest that has been written in any language.
On the other hand, there are instances, as might be expected, in which he has failed to hit the mark.
These latter may be placed in two classes: Firstly, those in which he indicates a partiality for personal acquaintances; and secondly, those in which he has followed popular opinion at the time, or the opinion of others, without sufficient consideration.