There are persons, mole-blind to the soul's make and style,It was the fashion in England at that time to disparage Emerson as an imitator of Carlyle; and this was Lowell's reply to it. He told Professor Hedge an amusing incident
Who insist on a likeness 'twixt him and Carlyle;
To compare him with Plato would be vastly fairer,
Carlyle's the more burly, but E. is the rarer;
He sees fewer objects, but clearlier, truelier,
If C.'s as original, E.'s more peculiar;
That he's more of a man you might say of the one,
Of the other he's more of an Emerson;
C.'s the Titan, as shaggy of mind as of limb,--
E. the clear-eyed Olympian, rapid and slim;
The one's two-thirds Norseman, the other half Greek,
Where the one's most abounding, the other's to seek.
This text is part of:
Table of Contents:
[98]
easy, nonchalant manner, which helps to mitigate its severity.
Thoreau could not have liked very well being called an imitator of Emerson; but the wit of it is inimitable.
“T. never purloins the apples from Emerson's trees; it is only the windfalls that he carries off and passes for his own fruit.”
Emerson remarked on this, that Thoreau was sufficiently original in his own way; and he always spoke of Lowell in a friendly and appreciative manner.
The whole poem is filled with such homely comparisons, which hit the nail exactly on the head.
The most subtle piece of analysis, however, is Lowell's comparison between Emerson and Carlyle:
1905. E. P. DUtton and Co. Boston,.
Tufts University. provided support for entering this text.
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.
An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.