rebelled against some of his rules, contending in a letter of selfvindication that they were begotten of fastidiousness, particularly in excluding words which were technical and half technical, or of Latin origin, and new words formed by the writer according to the analogies of the language.
often revised Dr. Howe
's writings, and only regretted that with reference to their full and permanent effect the Doctor
did not take more care in matters of style and arrangement.
He wrote concerning one of then: ‘I have read your manuscript carefully.
It is full of beautiful thoughts, often beautifully expressed.
The truths you seek to impress must prevail; but I am sure that they will sooner prevail if you will revise your copy before sending it to the printer. . . Your reports are classical documents.
If I regarded them only as commonplace documents I should be less sensitive to any defects of manner.’
wrote as to one of his reports as superintendent of the Blind Asylum
, which Sumner
had revised: ‘I want you to point out to me every fault, even to be more severe than you have ever been; for I am conscious that if I ever attain to any merit of composition, it will be through a perseverance on your tart in the friendly criticisms you have already vouchsafed to me.’1
But even the Doctor
, while gratefully acknowledging his service as critic, thought him wanting in the mirthful faculty, and in danger of ‘turning purity of style into purism.’
was in 1849-1850 a visitor at the Harvard Law School, the scene of his early studies.
On behalf of the visitors he made the report in which he stated the methods, advantages, endowments, and history of the School
, and the unexampled services of Judge Story
as teacher and author,—in gratitude for which a new professorship, to be called ‘the Story Professorship
of Commercial Law and the Law
of Nations,’ was recommended.2
His letter of July 15, 1851, to the Story Association
in which he recalls his loved teacher, as also two friends whom he had made in Europe
,—Thibaut and Mittermaier
,—marks the period of the end of his legal studies and his final withdrawal from the