[4] Πύλον. The position of the Neleian Pylos is an ancient subject of controversy. The Schol. on Aristoph. Eqq.1059 fills up Cleon's oracle “ἔστι Πύλος πρὸ Πύλοιο”, with the hemistich “Πύλος γε μέν ἐστι καὶ ἄλλη”. Compare Cellarius, notit. orbis ant. 1. 1188 ‘tres in Peloponneso Pyli, Eliacus, Triphyliacus, et Messeniacus: omnes alumno Nestore gloriabantur. Quod vero Nestoris possessiones Homerus ( Il.2. 591; 5.545; 11. 711) ad utramque ripam Alphei disposuit, Strabo inde, libro 8. p. 341, verisimillimum censet Pylum Nestoris fuisse Triphyliacum, qui solus fuit circa fluvium Alpheum.’ There is little or nothing to be said in favour of the Eleian Pylos, so that the claim lies between the Triphylian and Messenian. Strabo, as quoted above, argues strongly on behalf of the former; the latter view he says was held by “οἱ νεώτεροι ποιηταί”. His first argument is based on Il.5. 545“Ἀλφειοῦ ὅς τ᾽ εὐρὺ ῥέει Πυλίων διὰ γαίης”, but to this it may be answered that Pylos is loosely used in Homer to describe the whole Neleid Kingdom, as Strabo himself acknowledges, “Ὅμηρος δὲ ταύτην ἅπασαν τὴν χώραν μέχρι Μεσσήνης καλεῖ Πύλον ὁμωνύμως τῇ πόλει”. His second argument is more elaborate, from an examination of Nestor's description of the raids and reprisals between himself and the Epeians, Il.11. 670 foll. He decides that the circumstances there recorded follow each other too quickly to be compatible with the longer distances which the Messenian Pylos would necessitate. And here he decidedly makes a strong point. Again, he contends that the Neleian Pylos could not have been on the coast, as the Messenian is supposed to have been, because after Telemachus had embarked and had proceeded to Nestor's house he was obliged to send back a messenger to summon his companions from the ship ( Od.3. 423); and, in another passage ( Od.15. 199 foll.), the ship is again represented as being at some distance from the town. But we are still left in the dark as to the actual distance, and as to the position of the harbour with respect to the town. The testimony of the ancients preponderates decidedly in favour of the Messenian Pylos; Pausanias does not even allude to the existence of the Triphylian, while Pindar distinctly calls Nestor ( Pyth.6. 35) “Μεσσάνιος γέρων”, and the Scholl. on the present passage, as well as Eustath., declare for the same. The epithet “ἠμαθόεις” suits well with the Messenian Pylos, situated on the promontory of Coryphasium, at the north of the bay of Navarino. It may be uncertain whether the town of Pylos was somewhat further inland than Coryphasium, and the port alone was on the promontory; a view which would solve the difficulties stated by Strabo respecting the distance of the town from the sea. The coast line has no doubt materially changed in historical times (see Arnold, Thucyd. vol. 2, append.), but still it fully merits the Homeric epithet “ἠμαθόεις”, which epithet Strabo seems to have thought so strong that he attempts to neutralise it by interpreting it, contrary to all usage, as equivalent to ‘situated on the river Amathus’ (see Damm, Lex. Hom. s. v. Ἄμαθος). The strongest argument however in favour of the Messenian Pylos is the fact that Telemachus performs the journey from Pylos to Sparta in two days, without change of horses, passing the first night at Pherae; “λιπέτην δὲ Πύλου αἰπὺ πτολίεθρον”,
“οἱ δὲ πανημέριοι σεῖον ζυγὸν . . δύσετό τ᾽ ἠέλιος . . ἐς Φηρὰς δ᾽ ἵκοντο” ( Od.3. 485 foll.); and the next evening “ἷξον κοίλην Λακεδαίμονα κητώεσσαν” ( Od.4. 1). Now the Messenian Pylos, Pherae (at the head of the Sinus Messeniacus), and Sparta lie nearly in a line at intervals of about 30 miles. The Triphylian Pylos lies quite out of the way, and a traveller leaving that city for Lacedaemon would come down the valley of the Eurotas without approaching Pherae.Hide browse bar Your current position in the text is marked in blue. Click anywhere in the line to jump to another position:
book:
Book 1 (
α
)
Book 2 (
β
)
Book 3 (
γ
)
Book 4 (
δ
)
Book 5 (
ε
)
Book 6 (
ζ
)
Book 7 (
η
)
Book 8 (
θ
)
Book 9 (
ι
)
Book 10 (
κ
)
Book 11 (
λ
)
Book 12 (
μ
)
Book 13 (
ν
)
Book 14 (
ξ
)
Book 15 (
ο
)
Book 16 (
π
)
Book 17 (
ρ
)
Book 18 (
ς
)
Book 19 (
τ
)
Book 20 (
υ
)
Book 21 (
φ
)
Book 22 (
χ
)
Book 23 (
ψ
)
Book 24 (
ω
)
commline:
lines 1-1lines 2-3lines 4-5lines 6-6lines 7-7lines 8-8lines 9-9lines 10-10lines 11-13lines 14-14lines 15-15lines 16-16lines 17-17lines 18-18lines 19-19lines 20-22lines 23-23lines 24-26lines 27-27lines 28-30lines 31-32lines 33-35lines 36-40lines 41-43lines 44-44lines 45-47lines 48-48lines 49-49lines 50-50lines 51-51lines 52-54lines 55-56lines 57-57lines 58-60lines 61-61lines 62-62lines 63-63lines 64-64lines 65-67lines 68-68lines 69-71lines 72-72lines 73-75lines 76-78lines 79-80lines 81-81lines 82-82lines 83-86lines 87-87lines 88-88lines 89-90lines 91-94lines 95-95lines 96-96lines 97-97lines 98-98lines 99-100lines 101-102lines 103-105lines 106-107lines 108-108lines 109-111lines 112-112lines 113-115lines 116-116lines 117-117lines 118-118lines 119-119lines 120-121lines 122-122lines 123-123lines 124-125lines 126-126lines 127-127lines 128-128lines 129-130lines 131-131lines 132-133lines 134-134lines 135-135lines 136-136lines 137-137lines 138-138lines 139-139lines 140-141lines 142-142lines 143-145lines 146-149lines 150-150lines 151-151lines 152-152lines 153-153lines 154-156lines 157-157lines 158-158lines 159-159lines 160-160lines 161-161lines 162-163lines 164-164lines 165-167lines 168-168lines 169-169lines 170-176lines 177-177lines 178-178lines 179-181lines 182-182lines 183-183lines 184-184lines 185-186lines 187-187lines 188-188lines 189-189lines 190-192lines 193-193lines 194-194lines 195-195lines 196-196lines 197-202lines 203-203lines 204-204lines 205-205lines 206-207lines 208-213lines 214-215lines 216-216lines 217-217lines 218-221lines 222-223lines 224-226lines 227-230lines 231-231lines 232-234lines 235-235lines 236-239lines 240-241lines 242-243lines 244-244lines 245-245lines 246-247lines 248-250lines 251-251lines 252-254lines 255-258lines 259-259lines 260-260lines 261-261lines 262-262lines 263-265lines 266-266lines 267-268lines 269-273lines 274-275lines 276-276lines 277-277lines 278-279lines 280-280lines 281-283lines 284-285lines 286-286lines 287-289lines 290-290lines 291-291lines 292-292lines 293-293lines 294-296lines 297-298lines 299-300lines 301-303lines 304-305lines 306-306lines 307-308lines 309-309lines 310-310lines 311-311lines 312-315lines 316-318lines 319-319lines 320-320lines 321-321lines 322-323lines 324-331lines 332-336lines 337-339lines 340-340lines 341-344lines 345-345lines 346-347lines 348-348lines 349-351lines 352-352lines 353-354lines 355-356lines 357-360lines 361-363lines 364-364lines 365-365lines 366-366lines 367-371lines 372-376lines 377-377lines 378-380lines 381-381lines 382-382lines 383-383lines 384-388lines 389-389lines 390-391lines 392-392lines 393-395lines 396-399lines 400-400lines 401-402lines 403-406lines 407-407lines 408-410lines 411-419lines 420-420lines 421-421lines 422-424lines 425-428lines 429-432lines 433-434lines 435-436lines 437-437lines 438-439lines 440-440lines 441-443lines 444-444lines 445-449lines 450-452lines 453-455lines 456-457lines 458-459lines 460-460lines 461-461lines 462-463lines 464-464lines 465-465lines 466-470lines 471-474lines 475-475lines 476-479lines 480-485lines 486-487lines 488-492lines 493-494lines 495-495lines 496ff.
This text is part of:
Table of Contents:
Homer's Odyssey. W. Walter Merry. James Riddell. D. B. Monro. Oxford. Clarendon Press. 1886-1901.
The National Endowment for the Humanities provided support for entering this text.
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.
An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.